Hammer, Anvil, and the 20,000-Year-Old Border

By: Kenneth Henseler, 8-FEB-2026

A map recently circulated on Threads titled “Amount Of People Eligible to Be Mass Deported,” painting large swaths of the country in a stark red with numbers reaching into the millions. The immediate reaction from many, including talented craftsmen and “rebels” I respect, is a simple, “Do it.” But as any blacksmith knows, if the metallurgy of your foundation is cracked, the anvil will never ring true.

The “Nation of Immigrants” narrative we are all taught is what scholars call “the settler’s alibi”.[3] It is a rhetorical weld used to fuse the history of colonial conquest with the history of voluntary migration. But there is a fundamental difference: immigrants come in search of a homeland within an existing state; settlers come armed with a nationalist agenda to establish a state by displacing the original inhabitants.[5]

When we look at the “eligible” populations on that map, we are looking at people who often have deeper ancestral roots in this continent than the legal structure attempting to remove them. Archaeological evidence from White Sands confirms humans were thriving here 21,000 to 23,000 years ago—long before the glaciers even receded.[2] For over 97% of human history in North America, there were no “borders” in the sense we use them today.

Our current “right” to exclude is based on the Doctrine of Discovery—a 15th-century religious decree that claimed “discovery” by a Christian monarch conferred ownership, regardless of who was there first.[6] It is the ultimate establishment tool.

In blacksmithing, the heavy blow that is too forceful damages the work. A mass deportation program is that heavy blow. It threatens to fracture 5 million families and disrupt the very labor that sustains our communities.[7, 8]

If we applied the Haudenosaunee “Seven Generation Principle”—the idea that every decision must benefit the community seven generations into the future—would we choose a path of mass removal? [9, 10] A true rebel doesn’t just follow the state’s latest map; they question the state’s right to draw the lines in the first place. We are all arrivants on a land that has seen 20,000 years of stewards.[3, 11] It’s time we started acting like guests instead of owners.

Works Cited:
[1] Ellerman, A., & O’Heran, J. “Unsettling migration studies: Settler colonialism and the settler’s alibi.” Cenes Narratives. [1]
[2] Wolfe, P., & Veracini, L. “Settler colonialism: Logic and structure.” Wikipedia / Settler Colonial Studies. [1, 2]
[3] U.S. Geological Survey (USGS). “Tests confirm humans tramped around North America more than 20,000 years ago: The White Sands footprints.” UC Berkeley News / Science. [10, 3]
[4] “Seven generation sustainability: Origin and the Great Law of the Iroquois.” Wikipedia. [4, 5]
[5] Indigenous Corporate Training Inc. “The Seventh Generation Principle and the Great Law of Haudenosaunee Confederacy.” [11, 12]
[6] “The Doctrine of Discovery: Spiritual, political, and legal justification for colonization.” Lakota Times / Upstander Project. [6, 13]
[7] “Expansion and Manifest Destiny: Westward the Course of Empire Takes Its Way.” Smithsonian American Experience. [14, 15]
[8] “Consequences of family separation resulting from the deportation of a male migrant from the U.S.” NCBI / PMC. [8]
[9] National Association of Social Workers (NASW). “Near-Certain Cataclysmic Consequences of a Mass Deportation Program.” Social Justice Briefs. [9]

Care to read more? Here’s the full Deep Dive Research article we created earlier today: The Architecture of Dispossession: A Sociological and Historical Analysis of Occupancy, Sovereignty, and Migration in North America